Talmud Builders
    Course map
    Chapter 2 · The 39 Avot Melakhot

    Writing order - Writing and erasing

    Lesson 11 of 28 20 min

    Two melakhot, vast consequences. Writing is not only pen on paper: typing, photographing, drawing, even pressing a key that produces a letter - all are debated under "writing".

    Lesson goals
    • 01Define the liable writing measure: two letters
    • 02Distinguish biblical from rabbinic writing (ink type, temporary, non-lasting surface)
    • 03Know the dispute on digital writing
    01

    Building the Foundation: Writing – Definitions and Limits

    The melakha of 'Writing' is one of the 39 Avot Melakhot. It derives from the Tabernacle's work, where they wrote the names of the tribes on the Choshen stones and details of the sacrifices. But what exactly constitutes 'writing' for Shabbat purposes?

    כותבKotev
    A primary melakha prohibiting the creation of letters or meaningful symbols.
    משנה שבת יב:ג
    הכותב שתי אותיות, חייב. כתב אות אחת ועל גביה כתב אות אחרת, חייב.

    One who writes two letters is liable. If one wrote one letter and on top of it wrote another letter, he is liable.

    Insight

    The number 'two' is the cornerstone for understanding the melakha of writing. A single letter is not considered 'writing' in the halakhic sense, as it lacks sufficient independent meaning.

    02

    Biblical vs. Rabbinic Melakha: Deepening the Distinction

    Not all writing actions are equal in severity. Halakha distinguishes between writing that is 'de'Oraita' (biblical) and writing that is 'de'Rabanan' (rabbinic). This distinction impacts the severity of the prohibition and the ways it might be permitted in certain cases.

    1. 1De'Oraita writing: Must be permanent writing, on a lasting surface (e.g., parchment, paper), with ink or writing material intended to remain.
    2. 2De'Rabanan writing: Includes writing that does not endure (e.g., in dust, on steam), writing that is not discernible (e.g., with lemon juice visible only with heat), or writing not on a lasting surface (e.g., on food).
    3. 3The main difference: Karet or stoning for de'Oraita writing, rabbinic lashes for de'Rabanan writing.
    Insight

    The distinction between de'Oraita and de'Rabanan allows us to grasp the spirit of Halakha. The Torah prohibits the permanent act of creation, while the Sages extended the prohibition to cases that might lead to permanent writing or diminish the sanctity of Shabbat.

    03

    Writing in the Digital Age: Disputes and Implications

    The modern world has presented new challenges to halakhic authorities. Is typing on a computer, sending a text message, or even taking a photograph considered 'writing' on Shabbat? This is a complex question with deep disputes.

    Kushya

    Is digital writing 'permanent writing'? Letters on a screen are not etched into material, and they can be deleted instantly. On the other hand, they are meaningful and can be disseminated globally.

    Most halakhic authorities view digital writing as a rabbinic prohibition at the very least, due to 'weekday activities' or 'appearance of impropriety,' and some are stringent enough to consider it a biblical prohibition in certain cases. The complexity stems from the fact that digital writing is not physically 'on a lasting thing,' yet its results can be extremely lasting and significant.

    04

    The Melakha of Erasing: The Inverse of Writing

    מוחקMochek
    A primary melakha prohibiting the erasing of letters or symbols, whether to write in their place or not.

    The melakha of 'Erasing' is the parallel melakha to 'Writing,' prohibiting the erasing of letters or symbols. Here too, the minimum measure for erasing is two letters, and again, the erasing must be 'permanent' to be biblically prohibited. Erasing not for the purpose of writing, or erasing that leaves no impression, can be rabbinically prohibited.

    Insight

    Understanding the relationship between writing and erasing is crucial. Both are melakhot that alter the status of written information, whether by creating it or by removing it. Both require 'permanent intent' to be de'Oraita.

    Practice

    Explain: why is arranging magnet letters on a fridge permitted per most poskim?

    Lesson wrap-up

    Writing is the melakhah behind most modern technology questions on Shabbat.

    Check your understanding

    Test yourself before marking the lesson complete.

    Question 1 of 4

    What is the minimum measure of writing to be biblically liable for the melakha of 'Writing'?