Talmud Builders

    Commentary page

    Shulchan Arukh, Yoreh De'ah 348

    This page gathers the commentary on one source unit: the classic commentaries as they are printed, the sources the text cites, the sages named in it and direct links back to the text.

    Read the full text in the reader
    Shulchan Arukh · source analysis

    Yoreh De'ah Siman 348

    Yoreh De'ah Siman 348 is a source-text unit from the Shulchan Arukh with 3 seifim. Its reading map separates the practical rule, its conditions and the points that need comparison with the surrounding text.

    What to track

    Read each seif as a separate step. Identify the action, the condition that limits it and any distinction between cases before moving to the next seif.

    Study lens

    Look for rabbinic statements and attributed teachings, a turn toward a more precise resolution, interpersonal relationships and civil law. The source text remains the primary evidence; this note offers a structured way to enter it rather than replacing close reading.

    • rabbinic statements and attributed teachings
    • a turn toward a more precise resolution
    • interpersonal relationships and civil law

    A unit-by-unit map of all 3 seifim on this page: opening words, the moves the text actually makes and a link back to that exact seif.

    1. Seif 126 words

      Opens “דין שרפה על המת והאומר אל תקברוני.…”

    2. Seif 231 words

      Opens “האומר אל תקברוהו מנכסיו אין שומעין לו…”

    3. Seif 312 words

      Opens “אפילו מי שאין לו ממון שצוה ואמר…”

    Original text

    <b>דין שרפה על המת והאומר אל תקברוני. ובו ג' סעיפים:</b><br>שורפין על המלכים (או על הנשיאים) (טור בשם תוספתא) מטתן וכלי תשמישן אבל על ההדיוטות אסור:

    They burn at [the funerals] of Kings,’ (Jer. XXXIV, 5). These words were spoken to King Ẓedekiah. Nor does one transgress thereby the law which prohibits to ruin anything wantonly (Deut. XX, 19). On the contrary, honour is thereby extended to the Kings or Princes lest anyone makes use of their articles if left. Hence, only their beds or other articles of use are burnt, but nothing else — ShaK. or [ at the funerals ] of princes , on the authority of Tosef. — G. Princes are also mentioned in A.Z. ibid. Cf. however, Sem(H). VIII, 6. their bed[s] and articles which they used,’ (Jer. XXXIV, 5). These words were spoken to King Ẓedekiah. Nor does one transgress thereby the law which prohibits to ruin anything wantonly (Deut. XX, 19). On the contrary, honour is thereby extended to the Kings or Princes lest anyone makes use of their articles if left. Hence, only their beds or other articles of use are burnt, but nothing else — ShaK. but for commoners it is forbidden [to do so]. From this we learn that one should not destroy wantonly any garment whatsoever for the dead unless it is required for the shrouds — A.H.

    האומר אל תקברוהו מנכסיו אין שומעין לו אלא מוציאין מיורשיו כל צרכי קבורתו בעל כרחו וכן כל מה שרגילין לעשות לבני משפחתו ואפילו האבן שנותנין על הקבר והוא שירשו ממון מאביהם:

    One who gave instructions [that when he dies] he should not be buried at the expense of his estate, is not to be obeyed, but they collect from his heirs If he left enough only for his wife’s marriage settlement ( Kethubah ), he must be buried at the public’s expense — G.Mah. Ḥ.M. ibid. par. 30 where our present ruling is also found. [for] all his burial needs against their will, Cur. edd. have ‘his will.’ and likewise [for] all that is customarily done for [other] members of his family, and even [for] the stone that is placed upon his grave, derived from Asheri, San. § VI and in Resp. A tombstone may be erected over a grave at any time after the seven days of mourning — Mishmereth Shalom. also Ket. 5a, Tosaf. s.v. עד שיסתום . provided that they inherited money from their father. However, this is applicable only if he left instructions. Otherwise, the heirs, if well-to-do, must pay the expenses even if they did not inherit the estate — G.Mah. and B.Hillel supra § 344, 9, n. 24.

    אפילו מי שאין לו ממון שצוה ואמר אל תקברוהו אין שומעין לו:

    Even one who has no money, has, ‘even a dying person who has no heirs.’ Cf. BaḤ a.l. who gave instructions [that when he dies] he should not be buried [in order not to become a public charge], 47b, where it is stated that the decomposition of the body in the ground is a means of atonement for the dead). This question remains undecided. N states that since this involves a doubt concerning a ritual question, we adopt the more stringent view. Hence, the ruling here. Cf. also Yad, Zekiyah U-Matanah XI, 24. is not to be obeyed. adds, ‘for it is a disgrace for all living and not only for his family.’ supra n. 11.

    English translation: Code of Hebrew Law by Chaim N. Denburg, Montreal, 1955 · CC-BY