Commentary page
Shulchan Arukh, Even HaEzer 12
This page gathers the commentary on one source unit: the classic commentaries as they are printed, the sources the text cites, the sages named in it and direct links back to the text.
Read the full text in the readerEven HaEzer Siman 12
Even HaEzer Siman 12 is a source-text unit from the Shulchan Arukh with 4 seifim. Its reading map separates the practical rule, its conditions and the points that need comparison with the surrounding text.
What to track
Read each seif as a separate step. Identify the action, the condition that limits it and any distinction between cases before moving to the next seif.
Study lens
Look for rabbinic statements and attributed teachings. The source text remains the primary evidence; this note offers a structured way to enter it rather than replacing close reading.
- rabbinic statements and attributed teachings
Continue the sequence
Parallel sources
Lessons and study tools
A unit-by-unit map of all 4 seifim on this page: opening words, the moves the text actually makes and a link back to that exact seif.
Original text
<b>עידי גט וכן עדים שהעידו מיתת הבעל אם רשאים לישא האשה ההיא. ובו ד סעיפים:</b><br>המביא גט שצריך שיאמר בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם וכן העד האחד שהעיד לאשה שמת בעלה לא ישאנה משום חשד ואם כנס לא יוציא אבל המביא גט שאינו צ"ל בפני נכתב ובפני נחתם מותר לישא אותה כיון שאינה נשאת על פיו ושני עדים המעידים לאשה שמת בעלה מותר אחד מהם לישא אותה שאין שנים מצויים לחטא בשביל אחד ועיין בטור זה עצמו סימן קמ"א: הגה בתשובת הרא"ש שהביא בא"ע וי"א דאף בשנים אע"ג דשרי מ"מ בעל נפש ירחיק מזה (הגהות מיי' פרק י' דגירושין וכלבו ותוספות דיבמות):
One who brings a divorce document who must say: "In front of me it was written and in front of me it was signed," and likewise a single witness who testified for a woman that her husband died, may not marry her because of suspicion [that he lied in order to marry her]; but if he married her, he need not divorce her. But one who brings a divorce document who needn't say: "In front of me it was written and in front of me it was signed" [i.e. he is just the messenger and not a witness to its writing or signing] is permitted to marry her, since she is not [eligible to] marry based on his word. And two witnesses who testify for a woman that her husband died, it is permitted for one of them to marry her, since two people don't ordinarily sin for the sake of one [of them]. And see this in this Tur [Even haEzer] 141. Rem"a: In the responsum of the Ro"sh that he brought in Even haEzer. And there are those who say that even with two [witnesses testifying about the death of her husband], although it is permitted [for one of them to marry her], in any case a pious person will distance himself from this. (Hagahot Maimoni ch. 10 of Gerushin, Kol Bo, and Tosafot on Yevamot.)
אשה שנדרה הנאה מבעלה ולא הפר לה ובאה לפני חכם להתירה ואסרה שלא מצא לה פתח להתירה לא ישאנה שמא יאמרו אסרה כדי שישאנה ואם כנס לא יוציא וה"מ ביחיד מומחה אבל בי דינא לא חשידי ומטעם זה אם מיאנה או חלצה בפני ב"ד יכול א' מהם לישא אותה:
A woman who vowed not to receive any benefit from her husband, and he did not annul [that vow] for her, and she came before a Sage to release her [from the vow], and he forbade her [and as a consequence she and her husband must divorce] because he did not find for her an opening to release her, [the Sage] may not marry her, lest they say: "He forbade her in order to marry her." But if he married her, he need not divorce her. This applies to an individual expert, but a court [of three] is not suspected [of not releasing her from her vow so that one of them could marry her]. Based on this reason, if [a young girl] refuses [to marry a man whom her mother or brothers arrange for her to marry when she was a child] or is released from a levirate marriage in front of a court, one of them [= the members of the court] can marry her.
וכלם שנשאו לאחרים ונתאלמנו או נתגרשו מותרות לינשא להם:
And all of them who are married to others, and become widowed or divorced, are permitted to be married to them.
וכלם שהיו להם נשים באותה שעה ואחר כך מתו או שנתגרשו והיו הנשים הן שהרגילו את בעלהן לגרשן הרי אלו מותרות לינשא להם לכתחילה (היו נשותיהם חולים ומתו לא יכנסו) (נ"י פ"ב דיבמות) וכל אחת מהם מותרת לינשא לבן העד שהעיד לה או לבן החכם שאסרה על בעלה או לשאר קרובים דליכא למיחש שיוציאום מבעליהם בשביל קרוביהם:
And any of them who had wives at that time [that they testified about the death of a woman's husband or her divorce document], and afterwards their wives die or they divorce them, and it was the women who convinced their husbands to divorce them, they may marry [the woman about whom they testified] ab initio. Rem"a: If their wives were sick [at the time they testified] and die [after their testimony] they may not marry [the woman about whom they testified]. (Nimmukei Yosef ch. 2 of Yevamot) And every one of them is permitted to marry the son of the witness who testified for her or the son of the Sage who forbade her to her husband, or any other relatives [of the testifier or Sage], for none suspect that they removed them from their husbands for the sake of their relatives.
English translation: Sefaria Community Translation · CC0