Talmud Builders
    Course map
    Chapter 4 · Aramaic: the words of debate

    Kashya, teyuvta and teiku - how a debate ends

    Lesson 19 of 37 16 min

    Not every debate ends with an answer. We learn to tell an open difficulty from a full refutation and an undecided question - and what each means.

    Lesson goals
    • 01Tell kashya from teyuvta
    • 02Understand teiku
    • 03Mark the end of a sugya correctly
    01

    Three endings

    Kushya

    Kashya - a difficulty left unanswered, but the view is not fully rejected.

    Kushya

    Teyuvta - full refutation: the view is rejected because it contradicts an authoritative source.

    Insight

    Teiku - the question remains in doubt; the law follows rules of doubt.

    02

    Why it matters

    The distinction determines what remains as law. After "teyuvta" one does not rule like the rejected view. After "kashya" the view may still stand. A learner who marks the ending correctly knows what to take from the sugya.

    Practice

    Draw a three-column table - kashya, teyuvta, teiku - and add your own one-line explanation to each.

    Lesson wrap-up

    The end of the sugya is the bottom line. Read it carefully.

    Check your understanding

    Test yourself before marking the lesson complete.

    Question 1 of 3

    What separates kashya from teyuvta?